Subsidy program to fill empty storefronts may distort competitors, Montreal retailers say

Article content material

An opposition movement to subsidize new retail companies that open in areas with elevated emptiness charges may find yourself distorting competitors, service provider teams say.

Article content material

Ensemble Montréal, the official opposition at Metropolis Corridor, is asking the Plante administration to create an occupancy help program to encourage new retailers to arrange store in vacant shops lining the hardest-hit purchasing streets.

Article content material

Metropolis councillor Julien Hénault-Ratelle, Ensemble Montréal’s financial growth spokesperson, says the occasion plans to introduce a movement calling for the monetary help on the subsequent municipal council assembly June 12. The subsidies may value the town as a lot as $34 million in whole over three years, with support for every storefront capped at $30,000 a 12 months, he stated.

“To assist retailers face the lingering results of the pandemic, we predict it’s the appropriate time to maneuver ahead with a subsidy program,” Hénault-Ratelle stated Thursday in an interview.

Article content material

Article content material

On-line commerce’s skyrocketing reputation because the begin of the pandemic is without doubt one of the key causes storefront vacancies in cities like Montreal stay stubbornly excessive. About 15 per cent of storefronts on the territory coated by Montreal’s enterprise growth companies — referred to as SDCs — are presently vacant, based on an open database arrange by the town. Vacancies had been about 14 per cent in 2015 earlier than spiking in the course of the pandemic, Ensemble Montréal says.

“No one goes into enterprise for subsidies,” Glenn Castanheira, managing director of the Montréal Centre-Ville downtown retailers affiliation, stated Thursday in an interview. “Within the case of Montréal Centre-Ville, we might see some type of inequity and a problem with competitiveness with subsidies of that nature. It may even delay the opening of shops which are already deliberate so that individuals can obtain subsidies. So I’m not too positive about that decision.”

Article content material

Areas with comparatively excessive retail vacancies embrace the Latin Quarter close to the Berri-UQAM métro station, Ste-Catherine St. E. in Hochelaga-Maisonneuve, St-Denis St. and the Village, Hénault-Ratelle stated.

Though storefront vacancies downtown proceed to hover across the 20-per-cent mark, retail exercise within the space is choosing up — as evidenced by the very fact retailer openings in 2023 have outnumbered closings by 4 to 1, Castanheira stated. By way of Could 1, some 46 shops have opened their doorways downtown this 12 months, in contrast with 13 that shut down, he stated.

Subsidizing new retailers “is a good suggestion, however subsidies at all times create a type of inequity,” Julien Vaillancourt Laliberté, head of the St-Denis St. enterprise growth company, stated Thursday. “It’s a bit of bit like when cell phone corporations give new clients rebates that aren’t provided to longtime clients. There must be a steadiness. Maybe present retailers may get monetary assist for issues like freshening up their facade.”

Article content material

Vacancies on St-Denis St., which averaged about 25 per cent in December 2020, have improved within the final two years, Vaillancourt Laliberté stated. They hit about 15 per cent in Could, in contrast with 14 per cent in March, he stated.

Following a prolonged public session begun in 2019, Montreal’s Fee sur le développement économique et urbain et l’habitation issued a report on vacant storefronts two years in the past that outlined 11 suggestions to assist enhance the state of affairs. Key parts included new growth and animation measures; the creation of a database of business area occupancy; and a tax freeze for 2021.

The Plante administration lately launched a brand new bylaw on constructing occupancy — now within the technique of being adopted — that units new upkeep requirements for vacant premises and boosts fines for non-compliance to as a lot as $250,000 for heritage buildings. The bylaw would require vacant buildings to be registered with the town.

Article content material

Reached by the Montreal Gazette for remark, a spokesperson for the Plante administration didn’t reply in time for publication Thursday.

Though Ensemble Montréal’s subsidy program would initially goal business streets which are a part of SDCs, it may doubtlessly be enlarged to any business avenue coping with a emptiness drawback, Hénault-Ratelle stated. The $34-million determine refers to a state of affairs the place 100 per cent of all vacant properties are rented, he added. Subsidy quantities might be tailored based mostly on native points akin to homelessness, he stated.

“Sure, it’s a monetary value for the town, however a renewed business vitality helps each present companies and residents,” Hénault-Ratelle stated. “When you could have many vacant properties, a number of points come up. SDCs have fewer sources as a result of there are fewer companies round to contribute. It additionally creates city scars that decrease the standard of lifetime of residents.”

Article content material

Some, like Montréal Centre-Ville’s Castanheira, say they would like to see tax {dollars} deployed elsewhere.

“We’d a lot relatively see the town spend money on the general public realm, retaining downtown clear and delightful — that’s what attracts companies — and making the taxes extra aggressive,” he stated.

Montreal “has to deal with the issue on the root, which is that small-business taxes are larger than elsewhere,” added François Vincent, Quebec head for the Canadian Federation of Impartial Enterprise. “It is advisable create successful situations, and that begins with a extra beneficial tax burden.”

[email protected]