Robert Libman: S-word creeps again onto political agenda in Quebec

Article content material

Quebec sovereignty was again within the highlight this previous week with the present era of protagonists rattling the cage.

Article content material

The Bloc Québécois, whose members of Parliament in Ottawa help the breakup of the nation, held a boisterous conference final weekend, with chief Yves-François Blanchet boldly touting his social gathering because the automobile to unite all sovereigntist factions.

Article content material

On the provincial degree, Québec solidaire, trying to find a brand new co-spokesperson to interchange Manon Massé, noticed main contender Ruba Ghazal announce this week the social gathering should communicate “much more” about independence.

The Parti Québécois, for his or her half, have seen their ballot numbers creeping upward just lately thanks partly to intelligent media performs by social gathering chief Paul St-Pierre Plamondon. This week, he offered a movement within the Nationwide Meeting — supported by the opposite events — to take away the publication ban on paperwork concerning alleged spending violations by the No facet within the 1995 referendum, which it gained by the narrowest of margins. (There was no point out of the hundreds of illegally rejected No ballots in some federalist ridings, however I digress.)

Article content material

Article content material

This all made for a lot hyped rhetoric within the francophone media, with commentators expressing the view that Quebec sovereignty is making a comeback on the political agenda. They cite causes that embody: the federal authorities’s initiative to usher in a big inflow of immigrants; administration of our borders; decrease than anticipated well being switch funds from Ottawa; supposedly strained relations between Quebec and the remainder of the nation; and court docket challenges in opposition to Invoice 21 (spiritual symbols) and Invoice 96 (language).

It’s attention-grabbing how sovereigntist politicians and commentators painting current federal authorities actions as antagonizing Quebec and serving to to reignite the sovereigntist flame. But, minority communities consider the federal authorities is being passive about id points and language laws, for instance, to curry favour with Quebec.

Article content material

In some ways, the notion of Quebec separation is counterintuitive. How would the political upheaval of independence tangibly profit Quebecers? Quebec is already in some ways a de facto sovereign nation in all however identify. It appears Quebec can and does no matter it needs. It has management over training, language, id in addition to immigration for essentially the most half. The federal government can circumvent the federal and provincial charters of rights with the however clause with hardly a peep from Ottawa. Even the current revision of the federal Official Languages Act appeared to require the blessing of Quebec’s nationalist authorities.

If Quebec had been to change into unbiased, it will nonetheless be an island within the North American sea of English. We might nonetheless want immigrants to outlive economically. Correct mastery of French, literacy ranges and faculty dropout charges wouldn’t essentially enhance. We might nonetheless have Quebec courts to interpret the Quebec Constitution of Human Rights and Freedoms when sure legal guidelines are challenged (until, after all, the however clause is invoked each time).

Article content material

As a “have-not” province, what Quebec wouldn’t profit from, nonetheless, are profitable equalization funds from wealthier provinces. There can be little cause to consider the remainder of Canada would stay formally bilingual. There would possible be far fewer anglophones afterward, and perhaps not constitutional ensures for English colleges, however how would that enhance Quebecers’ every day lives?

The idea of Québécois pleasure and aspirations of nationhood are respectable sentiments that burn within the hearts of many Quebecers. However most steadiness that with being pragmatic. Sovereigntist events and commentators can hold drumming up complaints, scapegoat anglophones or the federal authorities, or create any variety of causes to attempt to rile sovereigntist sentiment. However the notion that independence will deliver closure to all issues is a pipe dream.

The “risk” of separation has at all times been extra priceless for Quebec than the precise dream might ever be.

Robert Libman is an architect and constructing planning guide who has served as Equality Get together chief and MNA, as mayor of Côte-St-Luc and as a member of the Montreal govt committee. He was a Conservative candidate within the 2015 federal election. twitter.com/robertlibman