Robert Libman: Is cockiness catching as much as the CAQ?

Article content material

In navigating the proposed automobile tunnel challenge linking Quebec Metropolis and the South Shore metropolis of Lévis, the wheels could not have come off but, however the Coalition Avenir Québec authorities definitely appears to have blown a tire.

Article content material

A Léger ballot revealed this week, taken shortly after the CAQ introduced it was abandoning its a lot touted “third hyperlink” election promise, indicated the celebration’s worst numbers for the reason that 2018 election. The ballot lastly revealed some scratches in Premier François Legault’s Teflon, with a 14 per cent drop in reputation for his celebration within the Quebec Metropolis space and a reasonably vital 4 per cent decline throughout Quebec.

Article content material

Many individuals have been skeptical within the first place about this grandiose promise however the premier, a lot of his ministers and significantly candidates from the Quebec Metropolis area all insisted with conviction that the federal government would ship on the challenge. Éric Caire even promised to stop his seat if the challenge didn’t get executed. (It didn’t and he didn’t.)

Article content material

Article content material

Over the past election marketing campaign there had been murky references to feasibility research and experiences, however the premier was coy in answering pointed questions or giving particulars, and his celebration succeeded in sweeping nearly all of the seats within the Quebec Metropolis area. When the federal government introduced it was actually abandoning the challenge, it reeked of electoral opportunism. Hypothesis has been swirling about what experiences existed and what the federal government was hiding concerning the challenge or attainable variations.

It’s no secret the premier and his authorities have a tendency to return off as overconfident and cocky — that they will simply deflect criticism, shortcomings and failed guarantees and nothing will stick. However this time it appears like they may have gone too far. It wasn’t solely the betrayal of a key promise, which occurs usually sufficient in politics. This was made even worse by what appeared like rehearsed emotional apologies. Frankly, they seemed like novice actors painfully attempting to emote sincerity as they repeatedly fed us the road a few drop in post-pandemic site visitors to justify the cancellation. The command efficiency was highlighted by the tearful breakdown of Bernard Drainville, the MNA for Lévis.

Article content material

The query is whether or not that is the start of a sea change within the political panorama and the seemingly unshakable dominance of the CAQ. Legault has largely benefited from a fractured opposition, with 4 different major events splitting the vote. The Léger ballot confirmed the CAQ lack of 4 factors was absorbed by the Parti Québécois, which seems to be solidifying second place and now trails the CAQ by 14 factors. The PQ, nevertheless, nonetheless carries the bags of one other promised referendum that almost all Quebecers don’t appear to need.

Québec solidaire — sovereigntist, too, and really a lot to the left — additionally would appear to have a ceiling with solely a lot room to develop. The Liberals are nonetheless with out a chief, so their numbers — miserably decrease than ever — can solely go up over the subsequent few years in the event that they decide the fitting chief.

Article content material

None of those different events appear able to forming a authorities any time quickly, however every has some potential for seat progress if the CAQ continues to shed share factors. If voters really feel like they’re being performed, the streak of majority governments may come to an finish. At minimal, this can be a wake-up name about vanity, which many predicted could possibly be the CAQ’s Achilles heel.

For now, the CAQ can attempt to exchange its blown tire and transfer ahead extra cautiously. But when the celebration continues to recklessly take voters with no consideration, the street to a different majority authorities in three years could possibly be a lot bumpier than anticipated.

Robert Libman is an architect and constructing planning advisor who has served as Equality Social gathering chief and MNA, as mayor of Côte-St-Luc and as a member of the Montreal government committee. He was a Conservative candidate within the 2015 federal election. twitter.com/robertlibman