Allison Hanes: Tuition hike will hurt greater than Quebec's English universities

Article content material

The bombshell the federal government of Premier François Legault dropped on Quebec’s three English universities final week by doubling tuition for college students from out of province will little doubt be catastrophic for his or her enrolment.

However the punitive coverage introduced as a part of a brand new “offensive” to bolster the French language will injury far more than recruitment on the three colleges.

Article content material

Article content material

McGill, Concordia and Bishop’s College have lengthy drawn a good portion of their pupil our bodies from the remainder of Canada, a part of a wealthy custom of academic change, co-operation and alternative that has fostered tutorial excellence. It’s an association that additionally works each methods.

At a time of their lives when younger adults wish to unfold their wings and develop their horizons, some college students not solely search to depart house for his or her undergraduate or grasp’s levels, however to maneuver elsewhere within the nation. Many from outdoors Quebec are drawn to vibrant, thrilling, dynamic Montreal, probably the greatest cities on the earth to be a pupil. And a few Quebecers go in the wrong way.

What’s so flawed with that? Part 6 of the Canadian Structure governing “mobility rights” makes this potential — fascinating, even — promising that each citizen and everlasting resident has the “proper to maneuver and take up residency in any province and to pursue the gaining of a livelihood in any province.”

That’s why there’s no border checkpoint the place Freeway 20 turns into the 401, Quebecers who get harm snowboarding at Whistler are entitled to care at B.C. hospitals and Montrealers can get jobs in Toronto with no need a piece allow.

Article content material

Article content material

It’s all a part of being Canadian. And Canada, regardless of many regional cleavages, was nonetheless a rustic final time I checked. Oh yeah, and Quebec can be nonetheless a part of Canada.

However the Legault authorities, desperately in search of to bolster its hardline cred after a byelection defeat to the Parti Québécois, is now taking purpose at this freedom of motion, sense of journey and sentiment of belonging to the broader nation.

It’s portraying all these non-Quebec anglophones shifting to Montreal (or Lennoxville) as freeloading interlopers chargeable for the decline of French. Hey, they’re most likely those making the ears of French Language Minister Jean-François Roberge bleed by greeting clients with “Bonjour/Hello!” at downtown Starbucks cafés. The nerve.

Increased Schooling Minister Pascale Déry complained that lots of the college students who come to Quebec to check depart and so the province is making “a selection” to not subsidize their training anymore. Out-of-province college students are nonetheless welcome, she insisted — so long as they pony up $17,000 as an alternative of $9,000 to replicate the true price of their levels. That method, the contemporary proceeds may be funnelled again to underfunded francophone universities.

Article content material

Props to Déry for making the announcement sound like a wonderfully rational financial determination. Emphasizing that 80 per cent of francophones go to school in Quebec to justify turning the screws on these supposed outsiders will certainly idiot many francophones into considering this is sensible.

Nevertheless it’s simply populist pandering designed to fire up resentment. It ignores the very fact Quebec additionally has the bottom tuition within the nation for its personal residents, be they francophone or anglophone. So there’s a monetary incentive to remain house that doesn’t exist for college students within the ROC.

The $9,000 tuition that Quebec universities at the moment cost out-of-province college students is roughly consistent with what they might pay anyplace else within the nation. So even when differential charges have been controversial when launched 25 years in the past, they didn’t have the identical prohibitive impact as almost doubling tuition may have now.

Apart from, if Déry was severe about retaining these college students within the midst of a labour scarcity, she’d be working with anglophone universities on francization plans to get these regionally educated graduates to remain completely. McGill had been on the verge of unveiling simply such a technique when the Quebec authorities pulled the rug out from below the English universities.

Article content material

As a substitute, this myopic and discriminatory tuition scheme will perpetuate a brand new mind drain and hobble English universities, that are being unjustly singled out. It’s not solely counterproductive, it’s most likely unconstitutional (not that this authorities provides a fig in regards to the Structure).

It is a continuation of Legault’s lengthy sport to weaken the English group’s establishments, flip anglophone Quebecers into second-class residents and curtail the rights of minorities extra broadly.

It’s additionally one other instance of Legault’s extremely profitable effort to distance Quebec from the remainder of Canada. He’s a grasp at nursing grievances to persuade folks Quebecers are below “assault” when dealing with the slightest criticism, be it from the federal authorities, fellow Canadians or particular people.

If there was one group on this nation that may have a deeper understanding of Quebec’s historical past, distinctness and sensitivities, it’s all of the Canadian college students who’ve been educated at universities right here. They assist break down the Two Solitudes that persist between Quebecers and Canadians, in addition to anglophones and francophones.

Driving them away is the following step in Legault’s incremental march towards higher independence for Quebec. By erecting synthetic monetary boundaries, he’s undermining reciprocity. The much less publicity Quebecers need to different Canadians (and vice versa), the much less affinity, understanding and attachment will exist — and the extra Legault’s polarizing and divisive id politics are positive to resonate.

Elevating tuition for fellow Canadians at English universities is a brand new us-versus-them wedge aimed on the ties that bind this nation collectively.

[email protected]

Article content material

Article content material